No Heart of the Matter
by
How many movies are we going to have to sit through about Veronica Guerin, the Dublin journalist who chased the city's big drug pushers and ended up getting assassinated? In Ireland you can't go through any stretch of shops without seeing a book about her, and with Joel Schumacher's Veronica Guerin following When the Sky Falls (2000), there have been two major motion pictures.
The death of Guerin was important because it shocked the nation into realizing how far its evil barons would go; it also provoked a bunch of demonstrations, which led to constitutional reform that would ease prosecutions against organized crime. But all that is told to us in the last five minutes of the film -- the rest, like last time, is a bunch of pointless hero worship.
Joan Allen played Guerin before, and now it's Cate Blanchett's turn. I suppose it would be silly to actually cast an Irish actress. Blanchett says the word "scanger" just so we know everything is Authentically Irish, and we get a parade of manipulative shots of guys in leather jackets beating people up, or kids playing in streets that are littered with used up skag needles.
We're supposed to be horrified, and we're supposed to be amazed that Guerin has the guts to go and trade one-liners with criminals, but it's hard to concentrate on anything but the fakeness of it all. Every line either explains something in the plot or teaches us a little message.
All the cops and politicians are dumber than this lone warrior reporter, and the crooks are all movie villains. And yes, just like last time, the main body of the movie never makes clear why these events were important or what the logistics of crime reporting are actually like.
Veronica Guerin emerges as a movie in the same vein as The Life of David Gale -- it's a big, glossy flick that seems to be using the right tricks to get us teary-eyed but hasn't got any heart.
(Released by Touchstone Pictures and rated "R" for violence, adult language, and drug content.)
Complete review posted at www.ukcritic.com.